2. Who by Fire

To prevent Anna being blamed for the murder of a Royal Officer, Abe must find the culprit; Ben and Caleb interrogate Simcoe.

3. Of Cabbages and Kings

On the run from the British, Ben is betrayed by his own militia. Abe travels with Richard to New York to spy. Mary confronts Anna.

4. Eternity How Long

Abe and Richard grapple with orders to dig up gravestones; Ben and Caleb try to get their intelligence to General Washington.

5. Epiphany

Celeb and Ben follow mysterious orders; Washington's army crosses into enemy territory.

6. Mr. Culpeper

Abe heads to New York and runs into a desperate patriot along the way. Ben is tasked with creating America's first spy ring.

7. Mercy Moment Murder Measure

An old threatening presence returns to Setauket, worrying Abe that Anna is no longer protected.

8. Challenge

Anna looks for enemy intelligence at an exclusive gentleman's party against Abe's wishes.

9. Against Thy Neighbor

Simcoe tries to hunt out the rebel conspirators in Setauket. Ben is sent away on a secret mission.

10. The Battle of Setauket

Mary struggles when she realizes that Abe is a spy working for the other side. Ben and Caleb hope to save Patriot families when they carry out a raid on Setauket.